'Smart Money' Exiting The Housing Trade - Business Insider Login Login Username Password Remember me
Forgot username or password?
Login with Twitter Login with Facebook Login with LinkedIn Login with Google Register
Clusterstock Contributors Home Tech SAI Enterprise Science
David Karp Speaks: Here's Why I Sold Tumblr To Marissa Mayer
David Karp Speaks: Here's Why I Sold Tumblr To Marissa Mayer
Microsoft Invented A Tablet A Decade Before Apple And Totally Blew It
The New Bird Flu Will Spread More Easily Among Humans Than Other Bird Flu Strains Finance Clusterstock Your Money
Morgan Stanley Is Essentially Giving Up On A Business Wall Street Used To Love
Morgan Stanley Is Essentially Giving Up On A Business Wall Street Used To Love
The Stunning Fall Of Generation X [CHARTS] Markets
Why Stock And Bond Markets Are So Confusing Right Now Politics Politics Defense Law & Order
Obama Is Risking A Ton Of Political Backlash By Not Appointing A Special Prosecutor In The IRS Scandal
Obama Is Risking A Ton Of Political Backlash By Not Appointing A Special Prosecutor In The IRS Scandal
Despite Drone Transparency Push, White House Won't Comment On Big Strike In Pakistan
Man Linked To Boston Bombing Suspect Was Unarmed When Shot To Death By The FBI Strategy Strategy Careers Small Business
13 Schools Where It's Almost Impossible To Fail
13 Schools Where It's Almost Impossible To Fail
15 Essential Life Skills The Class Of 2013 Should Master
13 Schools Where It's Almost Impossible To Fail Entertainment
The Beautiful Young Daughters Of The Baldwin Brothers Advertising
This Is The Mixed-Race Cheerios Ad All The Idiots Are Complaining About Retail
A New Jersey Frozen Yogurt Chain Is Being Called 'The Hooters Of Froyo' Sports
Rob Gronkowski Has A Back Injury That Could Potentially Derail His Career Life The Life Transportation
11 Hot Products From Amazon's Brand New Male Grooming Department
11 Hot Products From Amazon's Brand New Male Grooming Department
You'll Be Able To Drive From LA To NY Using Tesla Superchargers By The End Of 2013 More Latest Video Lists The Hive Your News BI Intelligence Events About BI Events BI Intelligence Clusterstock Home Wall Street Hedge Funds Private Equity Culture Money Media Regulation Clusterstock 50Contributors Documents Jobs Follow us on Facebook and get updates from Clusterstock Contributors posted directly to your news feed Enter your email address and zip code to set up customized email alerts. Email Zip From To Email Sent! You have successfully emailed the post. Looks Like The 'Smart Money' Is Already Exiting The Housing Trade Tyler Durden, Zero Hedge | May 30, 2013, 12:06 PM | 3,234 | 9 EmailMoreShare on Tumblr
Tweet!function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs");EmailShare on Tumblr
jekemp / Flickr
Things That Make You Go Hhmm... Like Our Current Bizarro World US Cyber Chief: Military Is Unprepared For Hacking IceCap Asset Management: "Bernanke's Bouncing Ball" Last September, one of the original institutional investors in the housing-to-rent strategy, multi-billion hedge fund Och-Ziff called it quits on the landlord business. The reason: "the New York-based hedge fund is looking to sell now because the returns it is generating from rental income are less than expected and it is looking to take advantage of a recent rebound in home prices in northern California." As a reminder, the REO-to-Rental subsidized investment program, which led to an epic surge in demand for multi-family housing, i.e., rental, units was, together with offshore investors parking their cash in the US for safekeeping (taking advantage of the NAR's anti-money laundering check exemptions) and the big banks Foreclosure Stuffing, the key reason for the recent, stimulus-fueled and quite transitory bounce in house prices in assorted markets.
Still, OZ's exit of the business did not spook too many of the other remaining investors who simply had no better investment options, and in a world of POMO and FOMO, they saw no choice but to become ever bigger landlords.
Today, another one of the original "big boys" has called it curtains: "We just don’t see the returns there that are adequate to incentivize us to continue to invest", according to the CEO Bruce Rose of Carrington, one of the first investors to use deep institutional pockets (in this case a $450 million investment from OakTree) and BTFHousingD.
Rose's assessment of the market? "There’s a lot of -- bluntly -- stupid money that jumped into the trade without any infrastructure, without any real capabilities and a kind of build-it-as-you-go mentality that we think is somewhat irresponsible."
Of course, one can say exactly the same thing about virtually every other market where those gambling with "other people's money" have no choice but to ride the tide and dance as long as the music emanating from the Fed is playing. However, it is rare to see one (technically, another) voluntarily step out even as others are still locked into a market where the returns are no longer worth the effort.
One such gambler is Blackstone:
Blackstone Group LP (BX), the largest investor in single-family rentals, has spent $4.5 billion to amass more than 26,000 homes and continues to buy, according to Eric Elder, a spokesman for Invitation Homes, the rental housing division of the world’s largest private equity firm.
Blackstone’s net yields on its occupied houses are about 6 percent to 6.5 percent, Jonathan Gray, the firm’s global head of real estate, said during a May 3 conference call with investors. That’s before using leverage from a $2.1 billion line of credit the private-equity giant arranged in March from a lending syndicate headed by Deutsche Bank AG.
While about 85 percent of Blackstone’s renovated homes were leased, Gray said, “we’ve got an awful lot of homes to continue renovating.”
Blackstone can have its homes: it's a different question if it will have the rental cash flow also needs to make these investments a reasonable investment. According to Carrington at least, the answer is a resounding no. And if people think the bottom will fall out of the market when the Fed pulls the curtain, just wait to see what happens to housing when the day comes that Blackstone announces it is shifting from the net buyer to net seller.
Back to Carrington's rationale:
Carrington, which started in 2003 as a mortgage investment fund and has managed almost 25,000 rental homes for itself and others, has been joined by hundreds of institutional and international investors buying single-family homes after prices plunged following the housing crash. The firms are building a new institutional real estate asset class from the 14 million leased single-family residences that are worth an estimated $2.8 trillion, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc.
Even as demand for rentals rises amid a falling homeownership rate, yields are declining and companies formed to buy the homes that have gone public haven’t yet been profitable.
Funds are buying property now, including homes sold by Carrington, for rents that yield 6 percent to 8 percent a year, before costs such as insurance, taxes and vacancies, according to Rose. Carrington’s model called for mid-single digit net returns on annual rents on an unlevered basis, according to Rose. While returns would vary by market, they would generally be in the mid- to high teens over the duration of the holding period, with the profit from home price appreciation.
Others' experience justifies the logic:
Colony American Homes Inc., a division of Thomas Barrack Jr.’s Colony Capital LLC, has found tenants for only 51 percent of the 9,931 homes it bought for $1.4 billion, according to a filing yesterday with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
American Residential Properties Inc. (ARPI), a Scottsdale, Arizona-based real estate investment trust, and Silver Bay Realty Trust Inc., a New York-based single-family REIT, both reported losses in the quarter ending March 31. Owen Blicksilver, a spokesman for Colony Capital, declined to comment. Silver Bay CEO David Miller was unavailable to comment, according to Tricia Ross, a spokeswoman at Financial Profiles Inc. American Residential CEO Steve Schmitz and President Laurie Hawkes didn’t reply to e-mails seeking comment.
If nothing else, everyone now knows where the incremental "bubble" demand for housing has come from: not from the distressed end user of thes properties, for whom as we showed yesterday, the disconnect between real income and new home sales has never been wider: it was all large institutions who invested OPM, and chased any upward moving price with the fervor of a rabid dog.
But all things come to an end:
“All the people who made money during the gold rush in California, they were selling the buckets and shovels,” Gordon said. “I think there is gold in them there hills, but you’re going to have to dig deep. And hopefully you’re going to need more than one shovel.”
Carrington may start buying rental homes again when other large investors decide to sell after learning they can’t make returns that justify the prices they paid, Rose said.
“We’ll sit back in the weeds for a while and wait for a couple of blowups,” he said. “There’ll be a point in time when we’ll be happy to get back into the market at levels that make more sense.”
If the Chairman is serious about tapering, or even hinting of tightening at some point in the future, those blowups won't take too long. And so will the blowup in the illusion that the housing market is "recovering" on anything more than yet another cheap-money fueled bubble afforded to a select few who now have no choice but to "hot potato" properties amongst each other first on the way up, and soon, going down.
Recommended For You
Neil deGrasse Tyson Tells Us Why 'Star Trek' Is So Much Better Than 'Star Wars'
Captain Kirk or Picard?
Please follow Clusterstock on Twitter and Facebook. Tags: Housing, Private Equity, Hedge Funds, Zero Hedge | Get Alerts for these topics »
Advertisement: Short URL Share: Twitter Facebook Digg StumbleUpon Reddit LinkedIn Google+ Email More about embedding posts » Embed More about Alerts » Alerts Newsletter To embed this post, copy the code below and paste into your website or blog.600px wide (preview)
400px wide (preview)
300px wide (preview)
Blackboard Home »
Zero Hedge
SummaryZero Hedge is a finance blog that touts itself as "the world's premier source of cutting edge market data." Its anonymity permits its bloggers to generate content uninhibited, as its manifesto states, by political constraint....More »Recent Posts About Zero HedgeMARIO DRAGHI: Zero Hedge Readers Don't Understand The Euro CrisisImagine An Election Where ZeroHedge Was Surging In The Polls, And Had 100,000 People Coming To His RalliesGOLDMAN: Behavioral Biases Are Found In Every Aspect Of The Investment Process
Tyler Durden is a reference to the lead character in Fight Club. It's the pseudonym for Zero Hedge's key author(s) used to hide their identities. Recent PostsBillionaire Paul Singer Say...SETH KLARMAN: 'Investing, W...BRIDGEWATER: Italy Could Bl... Join the discussion with Business InsiderLogin With FacebookLogin With Twitter Login With Google Name (Required)Email Address (Required but never displayed)Comments Submit the comment for Insider Status The Water Cooler
Insiders 1 All Comments 9 Apply To Be An "Insider" » Loading Apply To Be An "Insider" » Looks Like The 'Smart Money' Is Already Exiting The Housing Trade Looks Like The 'Smart Money' Is Already Exiting The Housing Trade Over?
Welcome, !You are logged into Facebook
Social: |Your Activity |These articles have been shared on your timeline. You can remove them here:OptionsNotify me when a story is shared.
Yes
No Welcome, ! You are logged in with Google
Social: | Your Activity | These articles have been added to your Google activity log. You can remove them here: Options Notify me when a story is shared.
Yes
No Send Us A Tip!GetBusiness InsiderEmails & AlertsLearn More »Customized instant email alerts(sample)Business Insider Select(sample)SAI Select(sample)The Wire Select(sample)Clusterstock Select(sample)Money Game Select(sample)Monday Scouting Report(sample)War Room Select(sample)Sports Page Select(sample)Politics Select(sample)The Life Select(sample)Your Money Select(sample)Enterprise Select(sample)Advertising Select(sample)Getting There Select(sample)Science Select(sample)Lists Select(sample)Retail Select(sample)SAI Chart Of The Day(sample)Money Game Chart Of The Day(sample)Sports Page Chart Of The Day(sample)10 Things In Tech You Need To Know(sample)10 Things Before the Opening Bell(sample)Social Media Insights(sample)Instant MBA(sample)Marketing Mondays(sample)Closing Bell(sample)Smart Investor(sample)Breaking News Alerts(sample)Advertising: The Brief(sample)Law & Order Select(sample)Financial Advisor Insights(sample)Mobile Insights(sample)BII Mobile Insights(sample)Careers Select(sample)Military Select(sample)Advertisement LinkedIn Login Hot: LinkedIn In your network Student Test Scores Show That 'Grit' Is More Important Than IQ 13 Secret Features Hidden In Your iPhone Ex-Apple Employees Reveal How The Company Is So Good At Keeping Secrets Login with LinkedIn to see what your friends are reading on Business Insider.
Login with LinkedIn No articles have recently been shared in your network. More » Sponsored By Your Money NASDAQ Composite 3,491 +23.78 (+0.686%) S&P 500 1,654 +6.05 (+0.367%) NYSE Composite 9,460 +37.57 (+0.399%) Guns & SoldiersMeet The Top Graduates Of America's Finest Military AcademyInside The Connecticut Gun Factory That Is Leaving The State In ProtestThis Is What Happens When You Get Hit In CombatMost Read Read Commented Recommended Mary Meeker's Latest Masterful Presentation On The State Of The Web 781,939 Views
17 Things You Should Never Buy Secondhand 730,783 Views
See What Tennis Legends From The Past Look Like Today 580,143 Views
13 Secret Features Hidden In Your iPhone 574,680 Views
13 Things That Americans Do That The Rest Of The World Just Finds Bizarre 124 Comments
Step Inside The Connecticut Gun Factory That Is Leaving The State In Protest 113 Comments
Obamacare Is Driving Some Doctors To Stop Taking Insurance Altogether 110 Comments
The 7 States That The Rest Of America Would Like To Kick Out Of the Country 109 Comments
Loading, please wait... See more » Find A Job In partnership with Tech JobsMedia JobsFinance JobsC-Level JobsDesign JobsSales JobsSee All JobsThe Future Of MobileThe Social Media Advertising Ecosystem ExplainedThe Rise Of Social Commerce: How Tweets, Pins And Likes Can Turn Into SalesHow Location-Based Services Are Transforming The Mobile IndustryHTML5 Vs. Native Apps: Why The Debate Matters, And Who Will Win
AdvertisementThanks to our partners A-Z Index Companies Authors Categories LatestContributorsVideoFull Archives Tools Job Listings Document Center Lists & RankingsSilicon Alley 100 Digital 100 Silicon Valley 100 Clusterstock 50 The Most Important ChartsThe Life 50 America's Best Colleges Best Business Schools Sexiest CEOsMore Your Account Register Change Your Email Preferences About BI About Jobs at BI Masthead Contact Advertise Mobile Conflict of Interest Policy Contributors FAQ Follow BI Email Newsletters Alerts RSS Twitter LinkedIn Facebook Google+ Verticals Tech Entertainment Wall Street Markets StrategyCareersRetailSportsLifestyleScienceEnterprise ListsPoliticsDefenseLaw & OrderAdvertisingGetting ThereMisc.Your MoneyLatest * Copyright © 2013 Business Insider, Inc. All rights reserved.Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Serviceand Privacy Policy.|Disclaimer| Commerce Policy
Powered by MongoDB|Stock quotes by YCharts|Ad Serving by 24/7 Open AdStream | Made in NYC
View the original article here