Posts
Some have argued that this is the main bear argument on China right now.
Many are asking why this is the case? Where all the money's gone? And is China facing it's own Minsky moment — a phenomenon that refers to periods of speculation that lead to crisis and that was named after economist Hyman Minsky who wrote about the inherent instability of bull markets.
In a new note, Bank of America's Ting Lu writes that this has raised questions about whether the non-performing loan ratios are higher than expected, if there are more artificially propped up investment projects that are using new credit for interest payments, is there more speculation than people realize
"Property speculation and a rising number of zombie companies," partly explain the credit-GDP growth gap he write. "More careful study tells us that the gap is smaller than what had been believed due to double counting and other distortions, and a majority of the gap could be ascribed to reasonable changes in fundamentals and short-term factors which should not be extrapolated."
From Lu:
"In our view, the 12ppt gap could be decomposed as follows: 2.7ppt due to double counting of funding via non-banking intermediaries; 1.0ppt on FX loans which were used for speculating on RMB/USD appreciation; 0.3ppt on RMB loans used for faking RMB trade settlement; 1.5ppt on zombie companies as a result of bad investment; 3.5ppt on changing fundamentals such as automation, rebalancing and falling returns on FAI; and 3.0ppt on short term factors such as the increased volatility in commodity prices and eased (and cheaper) credit."
Here's a chart that breaks it down easily:
Bank of America
But Societe Generale's Wei Yao is not so optimistic. In a note, excellently summed up by The Financial Times, Yao used methodology from the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) to calculate debt servicing ratio and applied it to China.
Doing that she found, "a shockingly high debt service ratio of 38.6% of GDP, of which 9.2% goes to interest payment (=6.3%×145 % of GDP) and the rest principal. At such a level, no wonder that credit growth is accelerating without contributing much to real growth!
Yao does think the actual DSR is lower than her calculation but writes that "a non-negligible share of the corporate sector is not able to repay either principal or interest, which qualifies as Ponzi financing in a Minsky framework.
Two slightly different takes on what this means for China?
Lu doesn't see an imminent crisis but does see need for reform. "In our view the central government needs to take more responsibility in infrastructure spending, move some debt burden from local governments to itself, build a functioning municipal bond market, improve prudential regulations, restructure the stock markets to restart IPOs, and make it easier for the private sector to obtain both credit and equity funding.
He also thinks the credit-GDP growth gap will narrow to less than 3 percentage points in two years.
Yao on the other hand writes that this is all still being held together because the state backs both the banking system (not shadow banking), and their support to local governments. "We think this precarious equilibrium could last a bit longer but not much longer, particularly if the central government does nothing."
While this may make investors wary of a hard landing, she writes that it's a good sign that the new leadership is more tolerant of slower growth. She does however expect that we will see more "corporate defaults, rising NPLs, and some degree of credit crunch," in coming years.
Money Game Home Tech SAI Enterprise Science 
Yahoo Employee: The New York Post Is Full Of It, Marissa Mayer Gave Us ALL Awesome New Laptops 
14 Big Data Startups You're Going To Be Hearing A Lot More About 
A Beautiful Australian Lake Is One Of Earth's Last Untouched Waterways Finance Clusterstock Your Money 
DYLAN RATIGAN: Of Course I'm Having A Midlife Crisis! 
When It's Safe To Close Old Credit Cards Without Hurting Your Credit Score Markets 
STOCKS MAKE IMPRESSIVE COMEBACK AHEAD OF HUGE JOBS REPORT: Here's What You Need To Know Politics Politics Defense Law & Order 
NEW YORK TIMES: The Obama Administration 'Has Now Lost All Credibility' 
10 Things You Probably Didn't Know About The Agency That's Spying On You 
CAMP CUPCAKE: Take A Tour Of America's Cushiest Prison Strategy Strategy Careers Small Business 
12 Technologies That Are Improving At Insane Speeds 
20-Year-Old College Dropout Has A Plan To Save The American Clothing Industry 
Google Says It Can Predict Which Films Will Be Huge Box-Office Hits Advertising 
Meet The Execs In The Running To Be Procter & Gamble's New CEO Retail 
McDonald's Comes Even Closer To Offering A 24-Hour Breakfast Sports 
The Denver Nuggets Fire George Karl After He Won NBA Coach Of The Year Life The Life Transportation 
The 20 Most Expensive Cities In The World 
The 50 Sexiest Cars Of The Past 100 Years More Latest Video Lists The Hive Your News BI Intelligence Events About BI Events BI Intelligence Money Game Home Economy Markets Investing ETFs HiveContributors Documents Jobs Follow us on Facebook and get updates from Money Game posted directly to your news feed Enter your email address and zip code to set up customized email alerts. Email Zip From To Email Sent! You have successfully emailed the post. STOCKS MAKE IMPRESSIVE COMEBACK AHEAD OF HUGE JOBS REPORT: Here's What You Need To Know Rob Wile | Jun. 6, 2013, 4:00 PM | 752 | 10 EmailMoreShare on Tumblr\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\How Gold Is Mined\themoneygame\PinExt.png "Pin It")
Tweet!function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs");EmailShare on Tumblr
Flickr / Homies In Heaven
Rob Wile Contact: e-mail: rwile@businessinsider.com Subscribe to his twitter feed 
Loading Apply To Be An "Insider" » STOCKS MAKE IMPRESSIVE COMEBACK AHEAD OF HUGE JOBS REPORT: Here's What You Need To Know STOCKS MAKE IMPRESSIVE COMEBACK AHEAD OF HUGE JOBS REPORT: Here's What You Need To Know 
22 Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Totally Differently From Each Other 
The Rise Of Social Commerce: How Tweets, Pins And Likes Can Turn Into Sales Login with LinkedIn to see what your friends are reading on Business Insider. 
How Location-Based Services Are Transforming The Mobile EcosystemWhy Local-Mobile Marketing Is ExplodingThe Rise Of Social Commerce: How Tweets, Pins, And Likes Can Turn Into SalesMost Read Read Commented Recommended 
Find A Job In partnership with 
Tech JobsMedia JobsFinance JobsC-Level JobsDesign JobsSales JobsSee All Jobs The HiveAbout The Hive »What Smart People Are Reading Right NowIndia Central Bank Prohibits Sales Of Gold Coins Hedge3Thursday links: a more normal role Returns3Obama administration defends phone record collection |Reuters3China Export Gains Seen Halved With Fake-Data Crackdown -Bloomberg3:: Hedgeye ::2MoreLessSee All »AdvertisementThanks to our partners
A-Z Index Companies Authors Categories LatestContributorsVideoFull Archives Tools Job Listings Document Center Lists & RankingsSilicon Alley 100 Digital 100 Silicon Valley 100 Clusterstock 50 The Most Important ChartsThe Life 50 America's Best Colleges Best Business Schools Sexiest CEOsMore Your Account Register Change Your Email Preferences About BI About Jobs at BI Masthead Contact Advertise Mobile Conflict of Interest Policy Contributors FAQ Follow BI Email Newsletters Alerts RSS Twitter LinkedIn Facebook Google+ Verticals Tech Entertainment Wall Street Markets StrategyCareersRetailSportsLifestyleScienceEnterprise ListsPoliticsDefenseLaw & OrderAdvertisingGetting ThereMisc.Your MoneyLatest